Spend $130 on a Leatherman Wave+ and you get a tight, US-made 18-tool folding pliers backed by a 25-year warranty that owners routinely pass down to their kids. Spend $40 on a Gerber Suspension-NXT or a classic sliding-head Multiplier and you get a working pocket multitool for a third of the money, one you will not lose sleep over if it drops out of a boat or gets left in a ceiling crawlspace.
Across r/Tools and r/BuyItForLife, both names bring out stories of tools bought during the Clinton administration that still ride on belts today.
Folding butterfly handles vs sliding one-handed jaws
Leatherman builds traditional butterfly-style folding multitools in Portland, Oregon, with tight pivot tolerances, outside-accessible locking blades, and a 25-year repair-or-replace warranty. The Wave+ dominates recommendation threads; one r/BuyItForLife owner called it “my go to. The carrying case is great, and has all the tools I need. Got it as a gift, and use it everyday.”
Gerber attacks the category from two angles: budget spring-loaded butterfly tools like the Suspension-NXT, and sliding-jaw pliers like the MP600 / Multiplier that flick open with a snap of the wrist. When you are up a ladder holding a wire or pipe with your left hand, that one-handed pliers deployment is a real mechanical advantage. As one owner put it: “Gerber multiplier. One handed opening is a must for me.”
Buy Leatherman if you want buy-it-for-life
Fit, steel quality, and warranty support set Leatherman apart. You can open the main plain-edge and serrated blades, the wood saw, and the diamond-coated file with your thumb while the pliers stay folded closed, so it behaves like a real pocket knife before you ever unfold the jaws.
Longevity stories show up in almost every thread. One r/Tools owner reported: “I have a leatherman wave from 1999. It’s still works perfectly. Quality tool.” Another noted that a chimney sweep carried one daily in place of a heavy pouch of loose drivers. And for many buyers in r/BuyItForLife, a teenage Leatherman gift was the tool that convinced them to stop buying cheap hardware: “Got my first one at 14… it turned out to be my first quality tool. After that, I no longer buy junk.”
Buy Gerber if you want value and one-handed use
At around $40 for a Suspension-NXT, Gerber costs roughly a third of a Leatherman Wave+. It includes spring-loaded needle-nose pliers, a pocket clip, and outboard-locking tools at a price that fits a glovebox, tackle box, or work vest where tools frequently grow legs.
Gerber’s classic US-made sliding-jaw Multipliers also earn multidecade loyalty. One r/Tools veteran still carries the same pair bought over thirty years ago: “I still own and use two original blunt-nose Gerber Multiplier I bought in 1992. I have tried others since and I always go back to my originals.”
Price tags, steel consistency, and warranty claims
Leatherman’s downside is sticker shock. Paying $130+ for a pocket tool stings if you only use it to slice Amazon tape, pull a splinter, or tighten a loose cabinet hinge once a month. It is also dense enough in a front pocket that many owners switch to belt sheaths or lighter models like the Skeletool.
Gerber’s weakness is uneven quality across its broader catalog. While the US-made MP600 series and proven budget picks like the Suspension-NXT hold up well, some of Gerber’s bargain-blister-pack models use softer blade steel that dulls fast and frame pivots that develop play under heavy twisting. Stick to specific well-reviewed models rather than grabbing a random Gerber off an endcap.
Still, in everyday pocket chores the gap narrows quickly. One r/Tools user who lost a beloved Leatherman picked up a Gerber replacement and kept working without missing a beat.
Choosing between the Wave+ and the Suspension-NXT
If you want tight machining, replaceable hard-wire cutters, outside thumb-hole blades, and a 25-year warranty that turns the tool into a lifetime purchase, buy the Leatherman Wave+.
If you want a spring-loaded pocket multitool with a deep-carry clip for around $40, or you prefer sliding one-handed jaws, buy the Gerber Suspension-NXT (or step up to the US-made Gerber MP600 for one-handed wrist-flick pliers).
Remember that a pocket multitool backs up a toolbox rather than replacing dedicated tools. For building out a real drawer set, see our homeowner’s tool-buying guide and Klein vs Wera screwdrivers.
FAQ
Is a Leatherman worth three times the price of a Gerber? If you use a multitool several times a week and value US manufacturing, replaceable wire cutters, stiffer frame locks, and a 25-year no-hassle warranty, yes. For glovebox emergencies and light package duty, a $40 Gerber covers the basics for $90 less.
Which multitool lasts longer? Leatherman is more consistent across its entire product line and repairs or replaces broken tools for 25 years. Gerber’s classic MP600 Multiplier and Suspension-NXT hold up well, though lower-tier Gerber models use softer steel.
Which Leatherman do people recommend most? The Wave+ leads nearly every r/Tools and r/BuyItForLife thread thanks to its four outside-accessible blades (plain knife, serrated knife, saw, file), replaceable wire-cutter inserts, and bit driver.

