Every few months, someone on r/Cooking asks which kitchen gadget wasn’t worth the cabinet space, and hundreds of home cooks line up to confess their worst impulse buys. Almost every regretted item shares the same two flaws: it only does one job that a chef’s knife already does in ten seconds, and it takes five minutes of scrubbing little plastic crevices to clean afterward.
Before you buy a specialty slicer, a pod coffee machine, or a stocking-stuffer gadget for a home cook, read what happened when people brought these home.
The single-use gadgets people regret
Single-purpose fruit and vegetable cutters top every regret thread on r/Cooking.
The avocado slicer is the poster child. As one commenter on r/Cooking wrote: “Avocado slicer by oxo. My bf had to buy it to make avocado toast easier. Used it once and said he could have just used a knife and spoon. This coming from a man who refuses to turn on a stove.”
The pineapple corer fares even worse. Another cook in the same r/Cooking thread vented: “I hate single use gadgets. My husband bought a pineapple corer. Dumbest thing ever. It wastes a fair amount of the fruit, makes a mess and takes up space. I can do it much better with a knife.” Add multi-blade herb scissors (which mash cilantro into green paste between five dull blades) and cup-style flour sifters, which cooks call useless compared to tapping flour through a standard fine-mesh sieve.
Then there is the garlic press, which sparks a civil war in every thread. Critics hate scrubbing sticky garlic skin out of tiny metal holes; as one top r/Cooking reply put it, “I know lots of people love their garlic press, but I would rather chop garlic with a knife than wash a garlic press.” Another cook in the same thread agreed that “a knife is just more convenient to wash.”
The appliances that disappoint
Small plastic gadgets only waste ten dollars; countertop appliances waste seventy dollars and a square foot of kitchen counter.
The Keurig pod brewer takes the heaviest fire across both r/Cooking and r/Frugal. As one former owner summed it up, “the novelty wore off almost immediately. The coffee always tastes stale and the pods are overpriced.” Once you factor in the per-pound cost of plastic K-Cups and internal water lines that are nearly impossible to descale completely, most people switch back to a drip brewer, a French press, or an AeroPress.
Countertop bread makers and electric hand mixers also collect plenty of regret. Bread machines bake oddly shaped loaves with a paddle hole torn into the bottom crust, leading most bakers to switch to a Dutch oven or a stand mixer. And as for mandoline slicers, the complaint isn’t that they fail to slice; it is that they send home cooks to the urgent care clinic. One former owner on r/Cooking wrote, “I sold a really nice high end mandoline slicer because I sliced the shit out of my thumb with it. And I was being extra careful. Never again.” If you do keep a mandoline (like the cheap Japanese Benriner that r/BuyItForLife prefers over $100 models), pair it with a $5 pair of cut-resistant gloves, which r/Tools commenters say “should be included with every mandoline sold, like brakes on a car.”
Who this is for (and who can ignore it)
Read this if you are outfitting a small apartment kitchen, shopping for a holiday gift for someone who likes to cook, or tempted by a viral TikTok vegetable chopper.
Ignore it if a specific tool solves a daily annoyance for your hands or routine. If you slice five pounds of potatoes for gratin every Sunday, a Benriner mandoline plus a Kevlar glove saves twenty minutes. If you meal-prep bulk meat once a month, a vacuum sealer earns its shelf space, even if casual buyers let theirs gather dust.
The one cheap gadget worth owning
Ask the same grumpy r/Cooking threads which small tool does belong in every drawer and they point to a Microplane rasp grater.
Contrasting their worst and best purchases on r/Cooking, one cook wrote: “Useless: Flour sifter (the one that looks like a mug). Flour always sticks in the bottom. Useful: microplane grater. I use it for baking, for cooking, for cocktails.”
Originally designed as a woodworking rasp, the long stainless Microplane zests lemons and limes without digging into the bitter white pith, grates fluffy mounds of Parmigiano-Reggiano over pasta, turns whole nutmeg into fresh spice, and grates peeled ginger or garlic cloves into a fine paste in seconds. When you finish, you rinse it under the faucet for three seconds and slide it into a drawer.
What to buy instead
Instead of filling a drawer with $15 plastic unitaskers, put that money into three basics:
- A sharp 8-inch chef’s knife. A Victorinox Fibrox slices avocados, cores pineapples, minces herbs, and crushes garlic cloves with the flat of the blade, then wipes clean in five seconds. Read our breakdown of the best budget chef knife on Reddit.
- A Microplane zester. For around $15, it handles citrus zest, hard cheese, garlic, ginger, and whole spices while taking up almost zero drawer space.
- A simple coffee setup. An AeroPress, a French press, or a Moccamaster drip machine brews far better coffee than a pod machine at a fraction of the cost per cup.
You can see all the daily staples that passed our owner check in the kitchen tools r/Cooking reaches for every day, and how cooks weigh big cookware splurges in Lodge vs Le Creuset.
Where Reddit’s snobbery goes too far
Take r/Cooking’s anti-gadget purism with a grain of salt. Quoting Anthony Bourdain’s old line about unitaskers is an easy way to farm upvotes, and commenters sometimes forget that not every home cook has restaurant knife skills or pain-free wrists.
The garlic press is the clearest example. For every purist who mocks it, another home cook uses theirs four nights a week. Defending the tool on r/Cooking, one user wrote, “I genuinely don’t get the hate. I love my garlic press and much prefer the texture of garlic that’s been through it vs minced with a knife.” Another cook on r/Cooking explained why: “I LOVE garlic and the pre minced stuff is trash in my opinion. So now I can have as much garlic as I want in a dish without having to be annoyed by chopping it myself.” If you buy a sturdy model with a flip-out cleaning grid like the OXO Good Grips or the removable-insert IKEA press, rinsing it under running water right after pressing takes five seconds.
Common questions
What kitchen gadgets are a waste of money? Plastic avocado slicers, pineapple corers, banana slicers, multi-blade herb scissors, cup-style flour sifters, pod coffee makers, and cheap multi-blade slap choppers. All of them are slower to wash than using a chef’s knife.
Is a garlic press worth it? It splits cooks down the middle. If you mince one or two cloves at a time and have a good chef’s knife, smashing and chopping on the board is faster to clean. If you crush six cloves at once or hate sticky garlic fingers, a heavy press like the OXO Good Grips or Kuhn Rikon is worth keeping.
Are Keurigs worth it? Most Reddit coffee and frugal threads advise against them: the plastic pods are expensive per cup, generate daily trash, and brew weak coffee compared to an AeroPress or standard drip maker.
What kitchen gadget is worth buying? A Microplane zester/grater ($15), an instant-read digital meat thermometer ($15–$35), and a fine-mesh stainless strainer. They get used several times a week across dozens of recipes and rinse clean in seconds.
