A 12-inch Lodge cast iron skillet costs around $25 (less than the disposable nonstick pans most people throw in the trash every two years) and it will outlive your grandchildren.

That price-to-lifespan ratio is why cast iron has a cult following across r/Cooking and r/BuyItForLife. One r/BuyItForLife regular traced their entire interest in durable goods back to “when I got my first cast iron pan.” Another commenter on r/BuyItForLife summed up the consensus: “It’s not that niche luxury brands like Smithey or Finex aren’t terrific, but you can buy a Lodge for $20 and it’ll last you forever.”

Unless you want featherweight cookware or refuse to hand-wash a pan, a cast iron skillet belongs in your kitchen.

Why it’s a buy-it-for-life pan

Nonstick PTFE and ceramic coatings have a built-in expiration date. Even if you use silicone spatulas and wash them gently by hand, the slick surface eventually scratches, dulls, or flakes. Explaining the switch on r/BuyItForLife, one cook wrote: “The coating on a non-stick pan will fail, rendering the pan garbage. We have cast iron cookware pieces that are between 60 and 100 years old, and will outlast us. Lodge is an inexpensive, reputable brand that has been around since the 1800s.”

Those century-old heirlooms aren’t museum pieces; people still cook dinner in them every night. One user on r/BuyItForLife posted photos after making supper in an 1890s Wagner skillet, while another in a high-value purchases thread paired their 1998 All-Clad stainless set with “the Wagner cast iron skillet I got at a yard sale for $5 that will go with them, I bought in the 80s and have used ever since.”

Longevity wouldn’t matter if the pan cooked poorly, and thermal mass is where cast iron shines. Once you preheat a thick iron skillet for five minutes, dropping a cold ribeye or four chicken thighs into the pan barely budges the surface temperature. When r/Cooking asked members to name a single pan to do everything, one voter answered: “12 inch cast iron skillet. It’ll last forever, it’s non-stick, it can go from stovetop to oven, cleans up in a snap.” And in a thread ranking the kitchen gear worth every penny, cast iron took the top spot alongside a Dutch oven and a digital scale.

The catch: it asks something of you

Cast iron isn’t maintenance-free, and pretending it behaves just like Teflon sets beginners up for frustration.

First, it is heavy. Lifting a 12-inch Lodge loaded with roast chicken and potatoes out of a 425°F oven takes two hands and a dry potholder. Second, iron rusts if you leave it soaking in the sink or run it through the dishwasher. After cooking, you wash it in the sink with warm water, dish soap, and a brush or chainmail scrubber, dry it immediately with a towel, and wipe a drop of cooking oil across the warm metal.

Third, heat control takes a couple of tries to learn. Cast iron heats up slowly and unevenly on small burners, so you need to preheat the pan on medium-low for a few minutes before adding oil and food. Rush the preheat and eggs or fish will weld themselves to the bottom.

Who should own one

Buy one if you sear steaks, pork chops, smash burgers, or skin-on chicken thighs, bake skillet cornbread or pan pizza, camp over open fires, or want to stop rebuying disposable skillets. As one home cook put it on r/Cooking, “Quality stainless steel, carbon steel or cast iron pans will last you forever. They are truly a ‘buy-it-for-life’ proposition.”

Skip it, or pair it with a lighter pan, if you have wrist pain from heavy cookware, simmer lots of slow acidic tomato and wine sauces, or just want a zero-thought pan for scrambled eggs before work.

Where the cast iron worship overshoots

Spend ten minutes on cast-iron forums and you will see people stripping pans in lye baths and baking six coats of flaxseed oil onto the metal like they are painting a classic car. Ignore all of that.

Factory-preseasoned Lodge pans are ready to cook on out of the box. You don’t need exotic oils, you don’t need to fear a squirt of Dawn dish soap, and if you ever burn food onto the surface or let a spot of rust form, five minutes with steel wool and a thin wipe of canola oil fixes it completely.

Just as important, owning cast iron doesn’t mean throwing out every other pan in the house. Plenty of experienced cooks keep a three-pan rotation: cast iron for high-heat searing and baking, a tri-ply stainless steel skillet for pan sauces and acidic dishes, and a cheap nonstick skillet reserved strictly for low-heat eggs. As one commenter shared on r/Cooking, keeping a couple of inexpensive OXO nonstick skillets alongside forever pans keeps everyone in the kitchen happy.

The one to buy

Grab a standard 10.25-inch or 12-inch Lodge Cast Iron Skillet for around $20 to $30, plus a silicone hot-handle holder or a $10 stainless chainmail scrubber for stuck-on bits.

Boutique modern brands like Smithey, Field Company, and Finex machine their cooking surfaces smooth like vintage Griswold and Wagner pans, which makes them lighter and prettier on the stove, though they cook the same food for six times the price. Start with the $25 Lodge and let a year of bacon, cornbread, and roast chicken smooth out the seasoning naturally.

Common questions

Is a cast iron skillet worth it for a beginner? Yes. At $25, it is the cheapest serious pan you can buy, and you cannot permanently ruin it short of cracking the iron in half. Preheat it for a few minutes before adding food, use a little butter or oil, and dry it right after washing.

Can you use soap on cast iron? Yes. Modern liquid dish soap like Dawn does not contain raw lye and will not strip polymerized seasoning. Wash the pan with soap and warm water, towel it dry, and rub a tiny drop of oil over the interior if it looks dry.

Is an expensive cast iron pan worth it over a Lodge? Not for cooking performance. Boutique pans (Field, Smithey) and vintage pans (Griswold, Wagner) are machined lighter and smoother out of the box, which feels nicer in the hand, while a $25 Lodge holds heat and sears steak identically.

Cast iron or stainless steel? Cast iron holds more heat for searing steaks and baking cornbread, and develops a natural semi-nonstick patina over time. Tri-ply stainless steel heats more evenly, weighs less, goes in the dishwasher, and handles acidic wine or tomato pan sauces without stripping seasoning. See our companion guide on whether a stainless steel pan is worth it.

The bottom line

A $25 Lodge cast iron skillet costs less than takeout for two and outlasts every coated pan in the store. Buy the 12-inch size so you don’t crowd your food, preheat it before dropping meat in, dry it after washing, and enjoy having one pan in your kitchen that gets better every year you use it.

Outfitting the rest of your kitchen? Check out the kitchen tools r/Cooking reaches for every day and our Dutch oven comparison in Lodge vs Le Creuset. For the other forever-pan option, read is a stainless steel pan worth it, or browse all of our kitchen buying guides.