Get home at 6 p.m. to rock-hard dried black beans or a raw chuck roast and a slow cooker cannot save your dinner. Leave the house at 6 a.m. for a ten-hour shift and want hot pot roast waiting the second you walk through the door, and a slow cooker is still unbeaten. Despite sitting in the same aisle, an Instant Pot and a Crock-Pot serve two completely different weekday schedules.
Across r/Cooking, r/Frugal, and r/AskReddit, the debate settles quickly once you look at what time of day you do your prep, and why the “Slow Cook” button on an Instant Pot disappoints almost everyone who tries it.
Why an Instant Pot makes a mediocre slow cooker
An Instant Pot seals with a silicone gasket and traps steam at high pressure, raising the boiling point of water so collagen in tough beef shanks, pork shoulder, or unsoaked chickpeas breaks down in under an hour. It also browning-sautés directly in the stainless inner pot, steams vegetables, and cooks rice or yogurt.
A traditional ceramic slow cooker wraps a heavy stoneware crock in circumferential heating coils, simmering food gently from the bottom and sides for six to ten hours with zero pressure.
Because an Instant Pot heats only from a flat disc at the very bottom of a thin stainless pot, its “Slow Cook” mode struggles to heat thick stews evenly without scorching the bottom or leaving the top undercooked. As one top reply in an r/Cooking thread explained: “An Instant Pot doesn’t maintain a consistent temperature for slow cooking. It’s a good pressure cooker, but if you want to mainly do slow cooking, get a proper slow cooker.”
Buy an Instant Pot if you want speed and versatility
Pressure cooking turns weekend braises and dried staples into weeknight food. One owner in an under-$50 purchase thread kept it brief: “Instant Pot. If you never used a pressure cooker before they are life changing.”
For home cooks trying to cut takeout spending, speed at 6 p.m. removes the biggest excuse not to cook. From an r/Frugal thread: “I’m much more likely to cook from scratch knowing that it will do the job as fast or faster than the stove top and I don’t have to watch it.” Another cook uses it for bulk staples: “set and forget a lot of things given the pre-programmed settings and safety features. I’m able to use a lot of cheaper and dried ingredients.” Cooking a pound of dry pinto beans in 40 minutes without soaking overnight pays back the appliance cost fast.
Owners also lean on it for homemade bone broth from rotisserie chicken carcasses, easy-peel hard-boiled eggs, steel-cut oats, and shredded taco meat.
Buy a slow cooker if you want true set-and-forget
A slow cooker shines when your mornings are calmer than your evenings. A working parent in an r/Frugal discussion explained why nothing else replaces it: “a crock pot is necessary for working people such as myself… to drop food in first thing in the morning, then when I get home, dinner is done. I leave for work at 530am and I’m not home until 5pm.”
With only Low, High, and Warm settings, there are no sealing rings to odor-soak, no steam valves to vent, and no electronics to fail. Many owners keep the same ceramic Crock-Pot for decades, and another credited theirs because it “allowed me to cut my restaurant visits to once a month.” As an r/AskReddit commenter put it: “Throw shit in. Turn on. Go about your day. Then boom! Bomb food.”
Depressurizing wait times vs 7 a.m. prep
Both machines have quirks that catch new buyers off guard.
On an Instant Pot, a “15-minute” recipe takes closer to 40 minutes on the clock: the pot needs 10 to 15 minutes to boil liquid and build pressure before the timer even starts, plus another 10 to 15 minutes of natural pressure release afterward so meat stays tender. You also have to wash the silicone sealing ring, which absorbs garlic and onion smells.
On a slow cooker, the catch is morning discipline and counter bulk. As one frugal owner noted, the stoneware pot is “quite big & heavy & quite restrictive.” If you do not chop onions and load the crock before leaving for work at 7:30 a.m., a slow cooker cannot help you at dinnertime.
Matching the pot to your weekday schedule
Pick the Instant Pot Duo 6-Quart if you decide what is for dinner at 5:30 p.m., cook dried beans and grains from scratch, make stock, or want one stainless pot that sautés and pressure-cooks in under an hour.
Pick a Crock-Pot 6-Quart Slow Cooker if you prefer loading ingredients before work or on Sunday afternoon and letting low heat tenderize roasts, chili, or pulled pork over eight hours.
If your main goal is fluffy white or sushi rice rather than stews, see is a rice cooker worth it; for crispy weeknight roasting, see is an air fryer worth it.
FAQ
Can an Instant Pot replace a slow cooker? For pressure braising, yes: you can cook the same pot roast or chili in an hour instead of eight. However, its built-in “Slow Cook” button heats only from the bottom plate and performs poorly compared to a heavy ceramic slow cooker.
Which one saves more money on groceries? Both cut restaurant delivery bills. The Instant Pot saves extra money if you cook dry beans, lentils, and whole grains from bulk bags; the slow cooker costs less upfront (often $35 to $50) and turns cheap, tough chuck or pork shoulder into tender meals.
Do people own both? Many kitchens keep both: the Instant Pot for weeknight beans, broth, rice, and fast curries, and a basic slow cooker for all-day workday simmering and party buffets.

